The short answer

Compare new and used cars over the same ownership period and mileage. Add finance, upkeep and explicit assumptions about future resale to the purchase-price calculation, and assess how much uncertainty you can bear.

Who this guide is for

For anyone choosing between a new and used car within a set budget who wants to compare more than the advertised price.

Illustration of a generic new car beside an older car, with a notebook for comparing expenses
Compare the risks of ownership too

New or used is a decision about cost, time and risk, not just the year of manufacture. Compare both options over the same ownership period, with the same mileage and money set aside for unexpected expenses. The purchase price is the starting point; it does not answer which car will cost you less and fit your life better.

A used car at a low price can leave room for maintenance. A new car with suitable warranty terms can reduce some uncertainty about covered repairs. Both options can make sense, and both can become a burden if all your money has already been spent on purchase day. Start, then, with a comparison that also reveals what is still unknown.

Set the same time horizon before calculating

Choose an ownership period you genuinely plan, for example three years for this exercise, and mileage based on your own use. A comparison in which one car is calculated over a year and the other over five years is meaningless. Different mileage can also shift the result independently of whether the car is new or used.

Write down what the car needs to do over that period: passengers, parking, equipment and routes. A used car from a larger category is not necessarily the right alternative to a smaller new car, even if their prices are similar. Before calculating costs, make sure both meet your budget and driving-routine requirements.

Do not choose a future sale price in advance simply because it supports the decision you want to make. Build at least two scenarios and present them as assumptions. If a small change in future proceeds reverses the result, the financial conclusion is not stable enough to present as fact.

To compare fuel costs alone, run a journey calculation for each candidate using the same distance and price per litre, changing the consumption figure.

Calculate costs without counting the car twice

The economic cost of ownership includes the purchase price minus resale proceeds, plus running expenses and financing costs. Loan principal repayments are a way of paying for the purchase; if the car's price is already included, adding the principal again would count it twice. Interest and fees do need to be included.

In a purely hypothetical example, a car is bought for 100,000 ₪ and sold at the end of the period for 70,000 ₪. The difference is 30,000 ₪ before running costs and finance. Another car is bought for 75,000 ₪ and sold for 50,000 ₪, making the difference 25,000 ₪. These figures are not a forecast for any model.

The example leaves a gap of 5,000 ₪ before other expenses. You can now ask how much insurance, repairs, maintenance or finance will affect the outcome. This replaces a general statement about depreciation with a transparent calculation you can adjust. To build the entire budget, use the guide to car expenses.

You can isolate interest using the car finance calculation with the terms of the offer, adding the cost of credit to the purchase cost without counting the principal again.

Separate known information from risk

For a new car, ask for the total price, delivery date, specification and warranty terms. For a used car, add its service history, ownership documents and professional inspection results. The more complete the information, the more you can replace a vague concern with a specific expense or question.

Item New car Used car
Purchase price Written offer for the version Agreed price for the particular car
Upcoming expenses Based on the maintenance schedule and quotes Based on the schedule and inspection findings
Warranty Document and start date Remaining cover and transfer conditions
History Documents for the individual vehicle and its delivery Continuous records and inspections
Future resale Scenario assumption Scenario assumption

Purchase price

New car
Written offer for the version
Used car
Agreed price for the particular car

Upcoming expenses

New car
Based on the maintenance schedule and quotes
Used car
Based on the schedule and inspection findings

Warranty

New car
Document and start date
Used car
Remaining cover and transfer conditions

History

New car
Documents for the individual vehicle and its delivery
Used car
Continuous records and inspections

Future resale

New car
Scenario assumption
Used car
Scenario assumption

There is no need to pretend every fault can be predicted. You can establish that records are missing, a particular service is approaching or tyres need replacement, and obtain a quote. Separately, keep a reserve for the unknown. Do not call that reserve a repair forecast, and do not remove it because the car looks clean.

A warranty reduces some questions, not all of them

Read what is covered, what is excluded, how long remains and who provides service. A warranty does not promise the car will never be out of use and does not necessarily cover wear or routine maintenance. Terms vary between manufacturers, importers and extended-warranty schemes; no single number of years describes the whole car.

Toyota's Israeli warranty booklet, for example, defines separate cover for the vehicle and hybrid components. The example shows why you need to read the appropriate document; it does not provide an answer for another brand. For a used car, ask for confirmation of the remaining cover on the particular vehicle you are buying, not just an image from an old advertisement.

Consider time without the car too. Someone who can work from home assesses downtime differently from someone who depends on a car for their livelihood. Check roadside assistance and replacement-car services under the actual terms, distinguishing included services from paid ones. You do not need to predict the number of days out of use; you need to understand what you will do if they occur.

Licensing and maintenance costs do not disappear with a lower price

The Ministry of Transport and Road Safety's vehicle licence renewal page details the renewal requirement and rules relevant to different vehicle types. Distinguish between paying the vehicle licensing fee (אגרת רישוי) and needing a physical roadworthiness test (טסט) at a particular time. Do not assume that an exemption from an inspection means all licensing costs disappear.

Ask for the exact maintenance schedule and look at the expenses expected during your ownership period. A service due shortly after purchase belongs in the comparison even if the seller is not paying for it. So does a documented expense identified during inspection. On the other hand, there is no justification for adding a list of repairs to every used car when those faults have not been found.

Compare insurance using personal quotes for the same drivers and uses. A lower vehicle price does not by itself tell you what the premium will be. Ask about coverage limits, the excess and additional services too. This is a general comparison; an individual insurance decision depends on your policy and circumstances.

Ask what will happen if you need to sell earlier than planned. A one-off expense you spread over several years will then be divided over a shorter period, and the outstanding credit balance may differ too. You do not need to predict life changes, but it is worth knowing whether the decision remains manageable if the horizon shortens.

Check how much risk you can bear

Compare two scenarios for each car: normal plans and a less comfortable year. In the second, you can test an unexpected expense, a change in mileage or a sale price below the assumption. Do not combine every extreme scenario as though it were a forecast, but make sure even one fault will not disrupt the whole budget.

If the used car is cheaper but a possible repair requires money you do not have, the purchase may still be unsuitable. If the new car leaves you without a reserve and with only a long run of monthly repayments, it does not necessarily provide financial peace of mind either. The amount of uncertainty you can bear is part of the cost to you.

To inspect an actual used car, use the checks to complete before transferring ownership. This article helps you choose a buying route; it does not replace an inspection of the individual car you want to purchase.

Checklist before you continue

Choose the option that leaves you with both a suitable car and room to manoeuvre. The price difference matters, but so does what you have left after paying it.

Useful tools for this topic

Found an error or outdated information? Read how we handle corrections and sources, or email us: [email protected].